Unpacking the Debate: The Pros and Cons of AI in Education

The growing conversation about AI in education 

We used Brandwatch Consumer Research to see how mentions about AI and education are changing, finding they're on the rise.

Since 2022, mentions about AI and education have grown steadily. There have been over 470k mentions about the topic since the start of the year – offering plenty of conversations for us to explore. 

When diving into the emotion behind these mentions, we can see that opinions on how AI can both help and hinder learning are mixed. 

Almost 45% of emotion-categorized mentions about AI and education showed joy, making it the most prevalent emotion in the conversation. People and brands are heading to social media to share excitement about how AI is helping to aid learning.

From how AI is being implemented in classrooms to how people are using artificial intelligence in their personal time to expand their knowledge, AI is certainly an excellent tool for students and teachers to have in their arsenal – when used correctly. 

Negative mentions also tell an interesting story. Anger is the second most prevalent emotion when it comes to AI and education, with almost 60k mentions since the start of the year.

These mentions include students’ frustrations towards the lack of AI regulations in school, teachers’ concerns about students using AI improperly, and general questions about how learning might be impacted by AI. 

Fear and sadness are also key emotions in the AI and education conversation, with mentions including AI’s shortcomings and specific upset about how AI is impacting art-based courses.  

Let’s dive further into the concerns that come with using AI in an educational setting. 

Concerns about AI in education

UNESCO puts it well, stating that while AI has the potential to address some of the biggest challenges in education, its rapid advancements outpace regulatory frameworks. And this is where many of the challenges that come with AI in education stem from.

Many online mentions discuss worries about AI hampering learning. For example, concerns from students about peers over-relying on AI in an education setting. 

Other concerns stem from the issue of plagiarism. In fact, there have been almost 10k mentions about plagiarism specifically regarding AI in education since the start of the year.

Not all of these mentions are about students either, with some concerned about how professors are using it in insincere ways. From using AI to write emails to using it to mark assignments, there are several ways professors can utilize AI – yet some are more accepted than others. And the post below shows how using it improperly might alienate teachers from students. 

While using AI to write appreciation messages or personable emails to students might not be widely praised, some teachers are using AI in more effective ways.

For example, some professors are utilizing AI to grade papers, and it seems to be working exceptionally well. Governing.com interviewed a few teachers on this topic, and one said it’s helped her students to become better writers – “not because AI did the writing for them, but because automated feedback can tell students faster than she can how to improve."

In these instances, using AI for basic corrections, such as grammar and punctuation, can help teachers to provide faster feedback to students.

Let’s look at some other benefits of using artificial intelligence in an educational setting. 

The case for using AI in schools

As we mention in our latest Education Report, using AI for learning can help facilitate more effective and efficient educational practices. Essentially, it can make students’ and teachers’ lives much easier.

And there are plenty of online threads discussing how AI can be embraced in learning environments, as teachers are curious about how others are taking advantage of new tools. 

Responses on how to use AI in educational settings vary, including: 

• Creating courses and lesson plans
• Using AI as a virtual assistant for teachers
• Brainstorming project ideas

Automating administrative tasks can be made much easier using artificial intelligence too, providing more time for teachers to help students. 

Some professors even recommend teaching students how to write effective AI prompts. For example, with creative writing tasks like the below.